Help promote human rights in the Middle East and North Africa

Donate Today
Facebook-f Twitter Instagram Linkedin Youtube Envelope
Search
Close this search box.
  • English
  • العربية
  • About
    • Our Mission
    • What We Do
    • Who We Are
    • FAQs
    • Support Dawn
    • Work With Us
    • For the Media
  • Founder Jamal Khashoggi
    • Who Was Jamal Khashoggi?
    • Chronology of a Murder
    • UN Recommendations
    • International Reaction
    • In His Own Words
    • DAWN and Jamal
  • Countries
    • USA
    • Saudi Arabia
    • Egypt
    • UAE
    • Israel-Palestine
    • Jordan
    • DAWN's Culprits Gallery
  • Democracy In Exile
    • About
    • Submission Guidelines for Democracy in Exile
  • Advocacy
    • The Lobbyist Hall of Shame
    • DAWN's Culprits Gallery
    • Reforming Foreign Policy
      • Aid Conditionality
      • Human Rights Go to War
      • China
      • Yemen: Toward Sustainable Peace and Democracy
    • US Foreign Policy in MENA
    • Joint Advocacy
    • DAWN Foreign Policy Blueprint
  • Experts
  • Latest
Menu
  • About
    • Our Mission
    • What We Do
    • Who We Are
    • FAQs
    • Support Dawn
    • Work With Us
    • For the Media
  • Founder Jamal Khashoggi
    • Who Was Jamal Khashoggi?
    • Chronology of a Murder
    • UN Recommendations
    • International Reaction
    • In His Own Words
    • DAWN and Jamal
  • Countries
    • USA
    • Saudi Arabia
    • Egypt
    • UAE
    • Israel-Palestine
    • Jordan
    • DAWN's Culprits Gallery
  • Democracy In Exile
    • About
    • Submission Guidelines for Democracy in Exile
  • Advocacy
    • The Lobbyist Hall of Shame
    • DAWN's Culprits Gallery
    • Reforming Foreign Policy
      • Aid Conditionality
      • Human Rights Go to War
      • China
      • Yemen: Toward Sustainable Peace and Democracy
    • US Foreign Policy in MENA
    • Joint Advocacy
    • DAWN Foreign Policy Blueprint
  • Experts
  • Latest
Donate

Demolishing the Beirut Port Silos Will Deepen Lebanon's Collective Amnesia

May 6, 2022
in Democracy In Exile
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Authors

  • Soha Mneimneh
    Soha Mneimneh

    Soha Mneimneh is a Research Coordinator at the Beirut Urban Lab at the American University of Beirut.

    View all posts

  • Mona Fawaz
    Mona Fawaz

    Mona Fawaz is a Professor of Urban Studies and Planning at the American University of Beirut and a co-founder of the Beirut Urban Lab at AUB.

    View all posts

Lebanon's political class is determined to erase yet another one of its crime scenes: the site of the 2020 Beirut port explosion that rocked the city and damaged at least a third of its buildings, killing hundreds of people and wounding thousands more. The Lebanese government is planning to demolish the port's gutted grain silos, the only structure left standing near the epicenter of the blast, claiming they are at risk of collapse.

Demolishing the silos will put a nail in the coffin of a stalled investigation into the blast that this group of warlords-turned-statesmen are determined to shut down. It almost amounts to a national tradition in Lebanon. Since the end of the Lebanese civil war, it has become standard practice to disfigure and erase the marks of crimes committed against the country's civilian populations. The decision of whether or not to demolish the silos is unequivocally a political act, rather than a technical one. Like other Lebanese citizens committed to the cause of accountability, we advocate for preserving the remaining silos as a memorial that would embody the collective aspiration of a just and viable future for Lebanon.

Since their construction in 1970, the silos have been a familiar part of Beirut's skyline—a modern architectural layer integral to the city's built heritage, and an emblem of the era of state-building in Lebanon. At the time of the explosion, according to the Ministry of Information, the silos held 85 percent of the country's grain supplies. Following the blast, the site has acquired additional heritage value as a stark symbol of survival, commemorating a city and its people. Located only 85 meters from the blast's epicenter, 14 of the 48 silos still stand today. Although the structure has lost its function as a grain silo, its visible scars embody the public's outcry for justice and accountability. Combined with the nearby 43-meter-deep crater, the silos represent both the blast itself and the protests against those responsible for it.

Like other Lebanese citizens committed to the cause of accountability, we advocate for preserving the port silos as a memorial that would embody the collective aspiration of a just and viable future for Lebanon.

- Soha Mneimneh and Mona Fawaz

But today, their future hangs in the balance. A government demolition order was issued on April 14. Only one minister's signature stands in the way of their destruction. The same local and central planning agencies that failed to support the post-blast recovery and left non-governmental agencies in charge of repairing victims' homes now leverage an argument about "public safety" to justify razing the silos. Rather than prioritizing over 1,500 structurally damaged residential and commercial buildings in Beirut—most of which still need critical repairs—these officials have turned their attention to the port's silos. They commissioned a study on demolishing the silos, but when it came back ambivalent about the need to actually tear them down, only the sections that outlined the reasons for demolition were announced publicly. The entire process followed a pre-determined track toward total erasure.

Families of the victims have organized to insist on preserving the site as a physical testimony of the loss of their loved ones, but only after the investigation into the blast is complete and justice is served. Only then, they argue, can interventions be designed to turn the silos and their surroundings into a memorial. Heritage experts concur on the importance of preservation. A Beirut Urban Lab study conducted for UNESCO argued that the silos had important heritage value—a point endorsed by a group of 25 heritage preservation experts who submitted their own report to UNESCO and the Ministry of Culture, and by the Beirut Urban Declaration, an initiative by Lebanon's Order of Engineers and Architects advocating to rehabilitate heritage and reconstruct the social fabric of areas affected by the explosion. They all demanded the classification of the silos as "protected heritage." Similarly, experts from the Order of Engineers and Architects have unanimously recognized the value of the silos; the organization also provided the main group representing families, the Beirut Port Explosion Victims' Families Association, with a technical report to support the case for preservation. Despite the evidence, the minister of culture remains reluctant to classify the silos as a heritage site for protection, even though he had initially supported the classification.

What about the so-called structural question? Expert-led studies recognize the severe damage to parts of the remaining silos, without predicting a full collapse. The government's publicly commissioned report narrowly pointed to two options for demolition or consolidation, but without clearly recommending a course of action. The Order of Engineers and Architects' structural opinion indicates that given the level of documented damage to the silos, the rate at which they are tilting and their type of building material, a collapse is not likely, at least not in the short or medium term. There is expert consensus that the silos will not collapse immediately, and that a substantial section of the building—its six southernmost silos—is structurally sound. Irrespective of the structural integrity of all the remaining silos, experts also agree that the silo's site was contaminated and structurally compromised by the explosion, which means that it cannot serve as the location for future grain silos.

What a society chooses to commemorate—or to erase—has great consequences on its collective identity. It shapes the narratives that younger generations will learn as their shared history, and the physical landscapes they will grow to identify as their own.

- Soha Mneimneh and Mona Fawaz

Nevertheless, several Lebanese officials have presented the decision to demolish the silos as merely technical, dismissing preservation claims as "romantic." Yet the Lebanese public has ample reasons to be skeptical. Many recall earlier episodes of national history, most of all after the civil war in the 1990s, when supposedly weak structural integrity was cited to justify the demolition of dozens of buildings in Beirut's historic core. It soon became clear that those claims were bogus and the motivation for demolition was private profit: clearing land for lucrative redevelopment in the name of postwar reconstruction. Perhaps most poignant was the Rivoli Cinema building on Martyr's Square, a modern architectural emblem of Beirut's 1960s, which was strapped with explosives but resisted collapsing several times before finally falling. To date, its site still stands empty in the center of Beirut, the emblem of a reconstruction that failed to protect memory and was consequently unable to fully rebuild the city or the country.

Historic preservation is not a technical choice, but a profoundly political one. What a society chooses to commemorate—or to erase—has great consequences on its collective identity. It shapes the narratives that younger generations will learn as their shared history, and the physical landscapes they will grow to identify as their own. Preservation, in other words, is essential for societies to recall a shared history and strengthen community. Preservation is also a potential strategy for social and economic development, as it tends to boost public spaces and tourism. In the context of Lebanon, where communal strife and callous governance have dominated, heritage preservation can be even more—a way to maintain, rehabilitate and develop a collective narrative that could bring together divided communities, and perhaps help build an inclusive economy. It would do so by reversing the state practice of deliberate or forced amnesia, in which history books evade any discussion of shared history for the past 150 years and national traumas, most of all the civil war, are not memorialized in any way.

To many activists and heritage specialists in Beirut, it is no coincidence that successive Lebanese governments composed of or allied to individuals directly blamed for specific crimes—from all the horrors of the civil war to the port explosion in 2020—would look to prevent the memorialization of their victims' history. Lebanon's venal political class doesn't want these victims coming together as a society. But that is precisely why the silos at Beirut's port must be preserved.

An aerial view of the port of Beirut, showing the damaged grain silos and the crater caused by the colossal explosion of a huge pile of ammonium nitrate that had languished for years in a port warehouse, Aug. 7, 2020. (Photo by AFP via Getty Images)

Source: Getty IMages

Tags: Beirut port explosionLebanon
Previous Post

The Grave Risks of Western Complicity With Corrupt Arab Autocrats

Next Post

Jordan: Reject Draft Law Criminalizing "Public" Suicide

Related Posts

Democracy In Exile

Derna's Man-Made Disaster and the Tragedy of Libya's Fate

It won’t just be nature’s fury that will haunt Derna’s residents, but the storm of negligence, manipulation and repression...

Emadeddin Badi
September 21, 2023
Democracy In Exile

After Morocco's Earthquake, Will Amazigh Life in the High Atlas Ever Be the Same?

Not all of the destruction from Morocco's devastating earthquake can be quantified in the country's rural, indigenous communities.

Brahim El Guabli
September 20, 2023
Democracy In Exile

The Regional Impact of Iran's Protests, One Year Later: A Democracy in Exile Roundtable

Has Iran’s repression of its protest movement reverberated beyond its borders?

Frederick Deknatel
September 18, 2023
TORONTO, ON - OCTOBER 2:  Lawrence Wright is seen behind his publisher's office in Toronto.
 In a region of ongoing violence and brutality, a 1978 peace treaty between Egypt and Israel has endured. Q&A with Pulitzer-winning Lawrence Wright on his new book Thirteen Days in September, which explains how it happened.
Democracy In Exile

Lawrence Wright on Why Domestic Terrorism Is America's 'Present Enemy'

Twenty-two years after the terrorist attacks of 9/11, the biggest threat to the United States is not al-Qaeda or...

Omid Memarian
September 14, 2023
Next Post
AMMAN, JORDAN - NOVEMBER 15: (----EDITORIAL USE ONLY â MANDATORY CREDIT - "ROYAL HASHEMITE COURT / HANDOUT" - NO MARKETING NO ADVERTISING CAMPAIGNS - DISTRIBUTED AS A SERVICE TO CLIENTS----) Jordanian King Abdullah II makes a speech at the parliament building during the inauguration of the new term of the Jordanian Parliament, in Amman, Jordan on November 15, 2021. In his speech, the king gave a message of support to the Palestinians. (Photo by Royal Hashemite Court / Handout/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)

Jordan: Reject Draft Law Criminalizing “Public” Suicide

UNITED STATES - MAY 26: Sen. Bob Menendez, D-N.J., walks through the Senate subway in the U.S. Capitol on Wednesday, May 26, 2021. (Photo by Bill Clark/CQ-Roll Call, Inc via Getty Images)

U.S.: Suspend Military Aid to Egypt in Wake of Menendez Indictment for Corruption by Egyptian Government

September 23, 2023

Derna's Man-Made Disaster and the Tragedy of Libya's Fate

September 21, 2023

After Morocco's Earthquake, Will Amazigh Life in the High Atlas Ever Be the Same?

September 20, 2023

Categories

  • Advocacy
  • Aid Conditionality
  • Anonymous Interviews
  • Anonymous Interviews Egypt
  • Anonymous Interviews Saudi Arabia
  • Anonymous Interviews UAE
  • Cases
  • Cases Egypt
  • Cases Saudi Arabia
  • Cases UAE
  • China's Uyghur Repression
  • Countries
  • Culprits
  • Culprits Egypt
  • Culprits Israel
  • Culprits Saudi Arabia
  • Culprits UAE
  • DAWN
  • DAWN Foreign Policy Blueprint
  • Dawn's Advocacy
  • Democracy In Exile
  • Editor's Pick
  • Egypt
  • Feature
  • Fellows
  • Foreign Policy
  • Human Rights
  • Human Rights Go to War
  • International Actors
  • Israel-Palestine
  • Joint Letters
  • Jordan
  • Lobbyists
  • Lobbyists Israel Palestine
  • Palestine
  • Political prisoners
  • Press Release Egypt
  • Press Release Israel-Palestine
  • Press Release Jordan
  • Press Release Saudi Arabia
  • Press Release UAE
  • Press Releases
  • Saudi Arabia
  • UAE
  • Uncategorized
  • United Nations
  • US – Egypt
  • US – Saudi Arabia
  • US – UAE
  • USA
  • Yemen Conference

SUPPORT OUR MISSION

Donate Today

About Us

Democracy for the Arab World Now (DAWN) is a nonprofit organization that promotes democracy, the rule of law, and human rights for all of the peoples of the Middle East and North Africa (MENA).

Support Us

Donate Now

Newsletter

Facebook Twitter Instagram Linkedin Youtube

© DAWN All rights reserved. | Website Design by KRS Creative.

DONATE TODAY