Help promote human rights in the Middle East and North Africa

Donate Today
Facebook-f Twitter Instagram Linkedin Youtube
Search
Close
  • English
  • العربية
  • About
    • Our Mission
    • What We Do
    • Who We Are
    • FAQs
    • Support Dawn
    • Work With Us
    • For the Media
  • Founder Jamal Khashoggi
    • Who Was Jamal Khashoggi?
    • Chronology of a Murder
    • UN Recommendations
    • International Reaction
    • In His Own Words
    • DAWN and Jamal
  • Countries
    • Saudi Arabia
    • Egypt
    • UAE
    • Israel-Palestine
    • DAWN's Culprits Gallery
  • International Actors
    • DAWN's Advocacy
    • USA
    • Aid Conditionality
    • Human Rights Go to War
    • THE LOBBYIST HALL OF SHAME​
  • Democracy In Exile
    • About
    • Submission Guidelines for Democracy in Exile
  • Experts
  • Latest
Menu
  • About
    • Our Mission
    • What We Do
    • Who We Are
    • FAQs
    • Support Dawn
    • Work With Us
    • For the Media
  • Founder Jamal Khashoggi
    • Who Was Jamal Khashoggi?
    • Chronology of a Murder
    • UN Recommendations
    • International Reaction
    • In His Own Words
    • DAWN and Jamal
  • Countries
    • Saudi Arabia
    • Egypt
    • UAE
    • Israel-Palestine
    • DAWN's Culprits Gallery
  • International Actors
    • DAWN's Advocacy
    • USA
    • Aid Conditionality
    • Human Rights Go to War
    • THE LOBBYIST HALL OF SHAME​
  • Democracy In Exile
    • About
    • Submission Guidelines for Democracy in Exile
  • Experts
  • Latest
Donate

The Day Tunisia's Democracy Died

July 25, 2022
in Democracy In Exile
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Post Author
  • Shadi Hamid

    Shadi Hamid is a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution's Center for Middle East Policy. His forthcoming book is The Problem of Democracy: America, the Middle East, and the Rise and Fall of an Idea.

    View all posts

A year has passed since the start of President Kais Saied's slow-motion coup in Tunisia. That it was as slow as this was perhaps key to its success. I would rather not write this as a sort of political eulogy. But it seems appropriate to write in the past tense, at least for now. This isn't to say that Tunisians won't be able to wrest their country back from their would-be strongman. I hope and pray that they will. But on a week like this—with Saied moving to enshrine his authoritarian powers in a stage-managed constitutional referendum—it is worth speaking to the gravity of what happened.

In some sense, this is what Tunisians wanted. Not all Tunisians, of course. But most of them, according to various polls. They saw parliamentary gridlock, ineffectual coalition governments and economic collapse and were primed for a leader who could promise a radically different vision. That man was Kais Saied. Interestingly, Saied, a constitutional law professor and self-styled straight-talking populist, hadn't been particularly popular initially. In June 2021, his approval rating was only 38 percent. Yet after he dissolved the government and suspended parliament indefinitely on July 25, with the military's support, his approval rating shot up to 82 percent. For several months afterwards, it hovered around 70 to 80 percent, before declining somewhat. In a survey conducted this past December and January, the political scientists Alexandra Domike Blackman and Elizabeth Nugent found that close to 80 percent of Tunisians viewed the president's seizure of power favorably, while less than 15 percent thought it threatened democracy and basic rights. In other words, there is compelling evidence that a large majority of Tunisians were still at least somewhat supportive of the coup after having more than four months to reconsider the prospect.

To be sure, this survey data shouldn't be taken at face value. It's complicated. These figures do not measure enthusiasm. Or to put it differently, it is one thing to say you support something; it is quite another to act accordingly in real life. Attitudes are not equivalent to behavior. In an overview of various measures of support, Mohamed Dhia Hammami and Sharan Grewal argue that Saied's support is relatively shallow, reflecting a "silent" and largely apathetic majority. Moreover, dissatisfaction appears to have increased significantly in recent months. Nearly all the country's major political parties have been calling for either a boycott of the referendum or a "no" vote against Saied's constitution.

On a week like this—with Saied moving to enshrine his authoritarian powers in a stage-managed constitutional referendum—it is worth speaking to the gravity of what happened.

- Shadi Hamid

Still, the lingering question remains. Tunisia was supposedly the lone bright spot of the Arab Spring. How is it that a country and a people managed to squander such considerable gains so quickly? Again, it's complicated. I remember right after Saied announced the new order last July, various Tunisian friends and acquaintances told me to avoid jumping to conclusions. They felt, perhaps correctly, that I was too influenced by the 2013 coup in Egypt and that to compare Tunisians to Egyptians did a disservice to the former. They said that Tunisians were different. Inculcated in 10 years of democratic practice, they would never countenance a return to authoritarianism.

Unfortunately, this was not too different from what many supporters of Abdel Fattah al-Sisi's coup insisted in the days and weeks after he took power in Egypt almost a decade ago. For outside observers and analysts like myself, it seemed self-evident that what happened in Egypt wasn't merely a coup; it was a textbook case of a coup. It was almost as if Egyptians thought they were outside of history, immune to the political machinations that have ended democracy elsewhere. It is true that I, or anyone else writing from the United States or Europe, had the privilege of distance. We didn't have to live with consequences of our own opinions—or, more precisely, the consequences of elections of countries not our own. In this case, however, distance provided a benefit. Proximity, on the other hand, had a distorting effect. It is harder to judge a revolution—or for that matter a coup—when one is experiencing it in the flesh.

As it turned out, Tunisians or Egyptians weren't exceptional. That these coups were popular only reinforced the point. By definition, successful coups tend to enjoy popular support; otherwise, they wouldn't succeed.

Economies aren't something one man can fix alone. Democracy, however, is something one man can destroy—if enough people let him.

- Shadi Hamid

As for why so many Tunisian secularists and liberals—who might have otherwise been expected to defend democracy—found themselves tempted by Saied's strongman routine, part of the explanation lies in the Middle East's longstanding democratic dilemma. Appreciating democracy in theory is different than liking its outcomes in practice. In Tunisia, as in much of the rest of the region, democratization produced Islamist gains. Even as Ennahda, the country's main Islamist party, hemorrhaged support and popularity, it still ended up as the largest parliamentary bloc after the 2019 elections due to the fragmentation of its secular competitors. Rachid Ghannouchi, Ennahda's controversial co-founder and president, became speaker of parliament, the same parliament that Saied summarily shuttered on day one of his coup a year ago. As Sharan Grewal, Ian DeHaven and Salah-Dean Satouri noted recently in The Washington Post, the prospect of reinstating that dissolved parliament is a sticking point for the opposition, since it would mean a return to perceived Islamist control.

For many ordinary Tunisians, the sources of dissatisfaction were more general and universal. The 2011 revolution, like any revolution, brought with it great expectations. Those expectations were not met, in part because they couldn't be. Democracies, on average, deliver better economic outcomes in the long run. Citizens, however, don't live in the long run. Over 10 years, as Tunisia's economy struggled and then suffered, Tunisians suffered in turn. Kais Saied promised them a better life. What did they have to lose? The answer, sadly, is: a lot. Economies aren't something one man can fix alone. Democracy, however, is something one man can destroy—if enough people let him.

Tunisian President Kais Saied delivers a speech on the anniversary of the death of former President Habib Bourguiba, in Tunis, April 6, 2021.

Source: Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

Tags: Tunisia
Previous Post

Time Is Running Out to Save the Truce in Yemen

Next Post

Cementing Saied's Sovereign Dictatorship in Tunisia

Related Posts

Democracy In Exile

Saving Lives in Time of War

The alternative to war unconstrained by international humanitarian law is total war—war fought without any effort to minimize harm...

Kenneth Roth
August 5, 2022
Democracy In Exile

Sisi's 'National Dialogue' in Egypt Is Just More Regime Window Dressing

As with the lifting of the state of emergency, Sisi’s call for a "national dialogue" doesn’t represent a reversal...

Mohammad Fadel
August 2, 2022
CAIRO, EGYPT - FEBRUARY 11:  Anti-government demonstrators wave an Egyptian flag in Tahrir Square on February 11, 2011 in Cairo, Egypt. After 18 days of widespread protests, Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak, who has now left Cairo for his home in the Egyptian resort town of Sharm el-Sheik, announced that he would step down.  (Photo by Carsten Koall/Getty Images)
Democracy In Exile

Egyptian Activist Ghada Naguib, Stripped of Citizenship, on Her 'Fate in Forced Exile'

In December 2020, activist Ghada Naguib became the first Egyptian to be stripped of her nationality because of her...

Muhammad Kamal
July 29, 2022
Democracy In Exile

Cementing Saied's Sovereign Dictatorship in Tunisia

President Kais Saied’s new constitution in Tunisia is the codification of a permanent state of exception.

Noureddine Jebnoun
July 27, 2022
Next Post

Cementing Saied’s Sovereign Dictatorship in Tunisia

Saving Lives in Time of War

August 5, 2022
A Yemeni student is seen at the destroyed Shuhada-Alwahdah school in Al-Radhmah district, Ibb province, western Yemen, on April 12, 2022. Thousands of schools have been destroyed and abandoned in Yemen as a result of the civil war, according to teacher's unions, which warn that illiteracy among the younger generation is on the rise and the country's future is being gradually destroyed. (Photo by Mohammed Mohammed/Xinhua via Getty Images) TO GO WITH Feature: Students at Yemen's "rubble school" struggle to keep learning

Human Rights Go to War: Workshop Report and Recommendations

August 3, 2022
NEW YORK, NY - SEPTEMBER 9: Former Secretary of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security Jeh Johnson testifies during a special Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental affairs hearing on "The State of Homeland Security after 9/11" at the National September 11th Memorial & Museum on September 9, 2019 in New York City. The hearing featured three former secretaries of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security. (Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images)

Former DHS Secretary Jeh Johnson: Rescind Endorsement of NSO Group Following Rights Violations

August 3, 2022

Categories

  • Advocacy
  • Aid Conditionality
  • Anonymous Interviews
  • Anonymous Interviews Egypt
  • Anonymous Interviews Saudi Arabia
  • Anonymous Interviews UAE
  • Cases
  • Cases Egypt
  • Cases Saudi Arabia
  • Cases UAE
  • Countries
  • Culprits
  • Culprits Egypt
  • Culprits Saudi Arabia
  • Culprits UAE
  • DAWN
  • Dawn's Advocacy
  • Democracy In Exile
  • Editor's Pick
  • Egypt
  • Feature
  • Fellows
  • Foreign Policy
  • Human Rights
  • Human Rights Go to War
  • International Actors
  • Lobbyists
  • Palestine
  • Political prisoners
  • Press Release Egypt
  • Press Release Israel-Palestine
  • Press Release Saudi Arabia
  • Press Release UAE
  • Press Releases
  • Saudi Arabia
  • UAE
  • Uncategorized
  • United Nations
  • US – Egypt
  • US – Saudi Arabia
  • US – UAE
  • USA

SUPPORT OUR MISSION

Donate Today

About Us

Democracy for the Arab World Now (DAWN) is a nonprofit organization that promotes democracy, the rule of law, and human rights for all of the peoples of the Middle East and North Africa (MENA).

Support Us

Donate Now

Newsletter

Facebook Twitter Instagram Linkedin Youtube

© DAWN All rights reserved. | Website Design by KRS Creative.

DONATE TODAY