Help promote human rights in the Middle East and North Africa

Donate Today
Facebook-f Twitter Instagram Linkedin Youtube Envelope
Search
Close
  • English
  • العربية
  • About
    • Our Mission
    • What We Do
    • Who We Are
    • FAQs
    • Support Dawn
    • Work With Us
    • For the Media
  • Founder Jamal Khashoggi
    • Who Was Jamal Khashoggi?
    • Chronology of a Murder
    • UN Recommendations
    • International Reaction
    • In His Own Words
    • DAWN and Jamal
  • Countries
    • Saudi Arabia
    • Egypt
    • UAE
    • Israel-Palestine
    • DAWN's Culprits Gallery
  • Democracy In Exile
    • About
    • Submission Guidelines for Democracy in Exile
  • Advocacy
    • DAWN's Advocacy
    • The Lobbyist Hall of Shame
    • DAWN's Culprits Gallery
    • Reforming Foreign Policy
      • Aid Conditionality
      • Human Rights Go to War
    • US Foreign Policy in MENA
    • Joint Advocacy
  • Experts
  • Latest
Menu
  • About
    • Our Mission
    • What We Do
    • Who We Are
    • FAQs
    • Support Dawn
    • Work With Us
    • For the Media
  • Founder Jamal Khashoggi
    • Who Was Jamal Khashoggi?
    • Chronology of a Murder
    • UN Recommendations
    • International Reaction
    • In His Own Words
    • DAWN and Jamal
  • Countries
    • Saudi Arabia
    • Egypt
    • UAE
    • Israel-Palestine
    • DAWN's Culprits Gallery
  • Democracy In Exile
    • About
    • Submission Guidelines for Democracy in Exile
  • Advocacy
    • DAWN's Advocacy
    • The Lobbyist Hall of Shame
    • DAWN's Culprits Gallery
    • Reforming Foreign Policy
      • Aid Conditionality
      • Human Rights Go to War
    • US Foreign Policy in MENA
    • Joint Advocacy
  • Experts
  • Latest
Donate

The Fallacy of 'Defensive' Weapons Is Just a Ploy to Justify Arms Sales

December 9, 2021
in Democracy In Exile, Saudi Arabia
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • Raed Jarrar
    Raed Jarrar

    Raed Jarrar is the Advocacy Director of DAWN.

    View all posts

عربي

The Senate voted this week on S.J.Res.31, a joint resolution of disapproval that would have blocked the sale of $650 million worth of air-to-air missiles from the United States to Saudi Arabia. It was backed by an unlikely mix of Republicans and Democrats in a starkly divided Senate, including arch-conservatives Rand Paul and Mike Lee, and progressives Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren and Patty Murray.

But the resolution failed, 30-67, mostly because of the myth that the weapons included in the deal are only "defensive" in nature—280 Raytheon-built Advanced Medium Range Air-to-Air Missiles, known as AMRAAMs, that Saudi Arabia says its fighter jets need against Houthi drones from Yemen.

Earlier this year, President Joe Biden announced that he would no longer sell "offensive weapons" to the Saudi government that would assist in their ongoing military campaign in Yemen, which left many wondering what exactly the difference is between a "defensive" and "offensive" weapon. In a statement slamming the efforts in the Senate to block the Saudi arms sale, the Biden administration argued that doing so would "undermine the President's commitment to aid in our partner's defenses at a time of increased missile and drone attacks against civilians in Saudi Arabia."

But weapons are weapons. This new false dichotomy of "defensive" versus "offensive" weapons is nothing more than a political ploy to justify selling more arms to abusive governments like Saudi Arabia's. This arms sale represents a further backtrack on Biden's campaign vow that, as president, he would make the Saudi government "pay the price" for its killing of journalist Jamal Khashoggi—including by making it "very clear we were not going to in fact sell more weapons to them," especially to resupply the Saudi-led war in Yemen that has killed thousands of civilians and created the world's worst humanitarian crisis.

The Biden administration has fallen back on the fallacy of "defensive" weapons. Is there really such a thing, though? Not according to existing U.S. law.

- Raed Jarrar

Now, the Biden administration has fallen back on the fallacy of "defensive" weapons. Is there really such a thing, though? Not according to existing U.S. law.

U.S. law prohibits selling weapons, of any kind, to abusive governments. The Arms Export Control Act and the Foreign Assistance Act both established guidelines years ago that govern arms transfers to foreign governments. According to a policy analysis by the Congressional Research Service earlier this year, "the acts authorize the termination of future sales and deliveries if a recipient is found to be in substantial violation of a sale-related agreement with the United States or to be otherwise using such defense articles for unauthorized purposes." The Foreign Assistance Act, as well as executive branch policy, it added, "restrict certain sales of defense articles to foreign recipients found to have committed human rights violations." That would certainly include Saudi Arabia.

Section 502B of the Foreign Assistance Act states clearly that a "principal goal" of U.S. foreign policy "shall be to promote the increased observance of internationally recognized human rights by all countries," and that "no security assistance may be provided to any country the government of which engages in a consistent pattern of gross violations of internationally recognized human rights."

When it comes to supporting its so-called "allies" in the Middle East and North Africa, the U.S. government has historically ignored and circumvented clear U.S. law that prohibits transferring weapons to abusive governments.

- Raed Jarrar

"Security assistance" is defined by Section 502B to include "sales of defense articles or services, extensions of credits (including participations in credits), and guarantees of loans." This section of the law also defines security assistance to include military assistance, economic support, military education and training, peacekeeping operations, or antiterrorism assistance and "any license in effect with respect to the export to or for the armed forces, police, intelligence, or other internal security forces of a foreign country." Those are not vague definitions and terms, and they say nothing about a supposed distinction between "offensive" and "defensive" weapons.

"Gross violations of internationally recognized human rights" are not vaguely defined under the Foreign Assistance Act, either. According to Section 502B, in determining whether a government has engaged in such violations, the secretary of state is tasked with preparing a report to Congress—the annual Country Reports on Human Rights Practices, also known as the State Department's Human Rights Reports—with information on prospective foreign recipients of U.S. security assistance. Specified topics for the report include information on war crimes, crimes against humanity, genocide, extrajudicial killings, freedom of the press and other serious violations.

When it comes to supporting its so-called "allies" in the Middle East and North Africa, the U.S. government has historically ignored and circumvented clear U.S. law that prohibits transferring weapons to abusive governments. Israel and Egypt continue to receive billions of dollars in U.S. military aid every year despite hundreds of documented cases of gross violations of human rights. Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates and other Gulf states continue to seal U.S. arms deals worth tens of billions of dollars every year as well, regardless of their own long records of human rights abuses.

Rather than putting human rights "back at the center of our foreign policy," as Biden has declared in speeches since taking office, echoing his campaign promises, the Biden administration is repeating the exact same mistakes made by previous administrations. This administration did not even issue a "security waiver" or any other typical excuse to justify ignoring the law when it comes to the flow of arms to an abusive American ally.   

The mere fact that Washington is humoring this invented paradigm of defensive versus offensive weapons is a win for abusive governments like Saudi Arabia's, which the United States shouldn't be selling any weapons to, period. Although the Senate failed to block this deal, members of Congress should reject this new false paradigm and block any upcoming weapon sales to any abusive governments.

Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images
Tags: arms salesBiden AdministrationDefensive weaponsOffensive weaponsSaudi ArabiaUS arms deal
Previous Post

Media Advisory: U.S. Senate Fails to Block Arms Sale to Saudi Arabia

Next Post

House Foreign Affairs: Support H.R. 5665 Against Islamophobia

Related Posts

Democracy In Exile

'It's Not Something We Can Leave in the Past.' George Packer on the Iraq War's Long Legacy

“The question is, what did not go wrong?” George Packer says of the U.S. invasion and occupation of Iraq....

Omid Memarian
March 23, 2023
In this photo provided by Ibrahim Almadi to CNN, Saad Ibrahim Almadi sits in a restaurant in an unidentified place, in the United States, on August 2021.
DAWN

Saudi Arabia: Lift Travel Ban on US Citizen Released from Saudi Prison

Saudi Arabia should immediately lift a travel ban it has reportedly imposed on Mr. Saad Almadi,

DAWN
March 21, 2023
Democracy In Exile

The Unlearned Lessons of the Iraq War, 20 Years Later: A Democracy in Exile Roundtable

What lessons have still not been learned from the war in Iraq, 20 years after the invasion?

Frederick Deknatel
March 19, 2023
Democracy In Exile

Iraqis Deserve Justice in the Form of Reparations

The illegal, U.S.-led invasion of Iraq 20 years ago cannot be extricated from the deeper, darker history that helped...

Noha Aboueldahab
March 17, 2023
Next Post
People leave the mosque after the Ramadan Jummah prayer at the Islamic Center in Washington on August 13, 2010. Ramadan is the holiest period for the Islamic faith and honors what Muslims believe was the month in which the first verses of the Islamic holy book Koran were revealed to the Prophet Mohammed. Muslims all over the world abstain from eating, drinking, smoking and sex from sunrise to sunset during the month of Ramadan in order to purify themselves and concentrate on Islamic teachings.            AFP PHOTO/Jim WATSON (Photo credit should read JIM WATSON/AFP via Getty Images)

House Foreign Affairs: Support H.R. 5665 Against Islamophobia

'It's Not Something We Can Leave in the Past.' George Packer on the Iraq War's Long Legacy

March 23, 2023
In this photo provided by Ibrahim Almadi to CNN, Saad Ibrahim Almadi sits in a restaurant in an unidentified place, in the United States, on August 2021.

Saudi Arabia: Lift Travel Ban on US Citizen Released from Saudi Prison

March 21, 2023
An Iraqi woman with her children raise their hands as US soldiers from the 4th Infantry division search their house in Tikrit, 180 Kilometers (110 miles) north of Baghdad, 19 December 2003. US soldiers captured Saddam hiding in a hole at a farm outside his hometown of Tikrit on December 13.         AFP PHOTO/JEWEL SAMAD / AFP PHOTO / JEWEL SAMAD        (Photo credit should read JEWEL SAMAD/AFP via Getty Images)

'A Never-Ending Cycle of Failures.' The Legacy of the Invasion of Iraq, 20 Years On

March 20, 2023

Categories

  • Advocacy
  • Aid Conditionality
  • Anonymous Interviews
  • Anonymous Interviews Egypt
  • Anonymous Interviews Saudi Arabia
  • Anonymous Interviews UAE
  • Cases
  • Cases Egypt
  • Cases Saudi Arabia
  • Cases UAE
  • Countries
  • Culprits
  • Culprits Egypt
  • Culprits Israel
  • Culprits Saudi Arabia
  • Culprits UAE
  • DAWN
  • Dawn's Advocacy
  • Democracy In Exile
  • Editor's Pick
  • Egypt
  • Feature
  • Fellows
  • Foreign Policy
  • Human Rights
  • Human Rights Go to War
  • International Actors
  • Israel-Palestine
  • Joint Letters
  • Lobbyists
  • Lobbyists Israel Palestine
  • Palestine
  • Political prisoners
  • Press Release Egypt
  • Press Release Israel-Palestine
  • Press Release Saudi Arabia
  • Press Release UAE
  • Press Releases
  • Saudi Arabia
  • UAE
  • Uncategorized
  • United Nations
  • US – Egypt
  • US – Saudi Arabia
  • US – UAE
  • USA
  • Yemen Conference

SUPPORT OUR MISSION

Donate Today

About Us

Democracy for the Arab World Now (DAWN) is a nonprofit organization that promotes democracy, the rule of law, and human rights for all of the peoples of the Middle East and North Africa (MENA).

Support Us

Donate Now

Newsletter

Facebook Twitter Instagram Linkedin Youtube

© DAWN All rights reserved. | Website Design by KRS Creative.

DONATE TODAY