Help promote human rights in the Middle East and North Africa

Donate Today
Facebook-f Twitter Instagram Linkedin Youtube Envelope
Search
Close
  • English
  • العربية
  • About
    • Our Mission
    • What We Do
    • Who We Are
    • FAQs
    • Support Dawn
    • Work With Us
    • For the Media
  • Founder Jamal Khashoggi
    • Who Was Jamal Khashoggi?
    • Chronology of a Murder
    • UN Recommendations
    • International Reaction
    • In His Own Words
    • DAWN and Jamal
  • Countries
    • Saudi Arabia
    • Egypt
    • UAE
    • Israel-Palestine
    • DAWN's Culprits Gallery
  • Democracy In Exile
    • About
    • Submission Guidelines for Democracy in Exile
  • Advocacy
    • DAWN's Advocacy
    • The Lobbyist Hall of Shame
    • DAWN's Culprits Gallery
    • Reforming Foreign Policy
      • Aid Conditionality
      • Human Rights Go to War
    • US Foreign Policy in MENA
    • Joint Advocacy
  • Experts
  • Latest
Menu
  • About
    • Our Mission
    • What We Do
    • Who We Are
    • FAQs
    • Support Dawn
    • Work With Us
    • For the Media
  • Founder Jamal Khashoggi
    • Who Was Jamal Khashoggi?
    • Chronology of a Murder
    • UN Recommendations
    • International Reaction
    • In His Own Words
    • DAWN and Jamal
  • Countries
    • Saudi Arabia
    • Egypt
    • UAE
    • Israel-Palestine
    • DAWN's Culprits Gallery
  • Democracy In Exile
    • About
    • Submission Guidelines for Democracy in Exile
  • Advocacy
    • DAWN's Advocacy
    • The Lobbyist Hall of Shame
    • DAWN's Culprits Gallery
    • Reforming Foreign Policy
      • Aid Conditionality
      • Human Rights Go to War
    • US Foreign Policy in MENA
    • Joint Advocacy
  • Experts
  • Latest
Donate

The Silent Branch: How Israel's Supreme Court Crushes Palestinian Rights

January 26, 2023
in Democracy In Exile, Israel-Palestine
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
  • Hagai El-Ad
    Hagai El-Ad

    Hagai El-Ad is the Executive Director of B'Tselem, the Israeli Information Center for Human Rights in the Occupied Territories.

    View all posts

The president of Israel's Supreme Court, Justice Esther Hayut, gave an impassioned and historic speech this month criticizing the radical overhaul of the judiciary proposed by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's new far-right government, which she called a "plan to crush the Israeli judicial system."

"This is an unbridled attack on the judicial system, as if it were an enemy that must be attacked and subdued," she said of the scheme, which would significantly weaken the Supreme Court's authority. She warned that the plan would deal "a fatal blow" to Israel's "democratic identity" by turning the judicial branch of government "into a silent branch."

To make her point, Hayut cited eight examples of important Supreme Court rulings that, like every word in the carefully curated speech, were thoughtfully selected. According to the chief justice, these rulings exemplify "one of the major roles of a court in a democratic country… effective defense of human rights and civil rights." Protecting the rights of soldiers and of LGBT persons; defending religious rights; safeguarding the rights of children with special needs; installing shelters at schools in Israel's southern communities near Gaza; upholding freedom of expression and social rights—Justice Hayut was certainly judicious in her choice of rulings to mention. She was equally careful with what she chose to leave out.

The president of the Supreme Court made no mention whatsoever of Palestinian human rights. This omission cannot be accidental. After all, Palestinians are a large minority within Israel proper and make up half the population in the entire area between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea. Yet somehow, exactly when she was lauding the court's "effective defense of human rights and civil rights in the country," Hayut overlooked half the people who live under Israel's control—even though they are the group that suffers the broadest and most severe violations of their rights, which are ongoing. How can one honestly talk about protecting human rights in Israel without even mentioning these human beings?

As in the past, Israel's Supreme Court continues to faithfully play its role in this regime of Jewish supremacy.

- Hagai El-Ad

Hayut chose carefully. To please her Jewish audience, she mentioned no ruling concerning Palestinians, on either side of the Green Line (her reference to the Hassan case, regarding the Income Support Law that was ruled unconstitutional, made no dent in this wholesale omission).

The truth is, she had a wealth of examples to choose from. She could have cited the rulings that greenlighted the expulsion of entire Palestinian communities in the West Bank, such as Khan al-Ahmar or the communities of Masafer Yatta. She could have talked about the regular sanctioning, in hundreds of cruel rulings, of collective punishment in the form of demolishing the homes of Palestinian families whose relatives attacked Israelis. She could have mentioned the rulings that advanced the takeover of Palestinian land or approved Israel's policy in Gaza. She could have noted that the Supreme Court has upheld the "Admission Committees Law," effectively banning Palestinians from hundreds of communities in Israel; the "Nakba Law," imposing limitations on commemoration of the Nakba; the "Citizenship Law," barring Palestinian spouses from gaining legal status in Israel; and the "Nation-State Law," exclusively defining the state on ethnic Jewish terms.

Yet the president of the Supreme Court chose to note none of the above, and to thus play exactly the role she was cautioning against—that of the "silent branch" of government.

Why did Justice Hayut choose silence? Of course, she wanted to defend the liberal image of the Supreme Court and of the Jewish state. That is why she could not flaunt the court's role, under her leadership and that of her predecessors, in legally approving the systemic trampling of Palestinians' human rights under the Israeli regime. It simply doesn't add up: a rich history of sanctioning systemic harm to Palestinians with a proud defense of human rights. The only choice she had was to remain silent—in a dramatic, landmark speech that purported to speak for human rights.

Further, the current debate in Israel is not about the actual oppression of Palestinians—a matter of broad consensus—but about how and to what extent their rights should be trampled. As in the past, the Supreme Court continues to faithfully play its role in this regime of Jewish supremacy. Yet growing numbers of Jews in Israel have internalized "the fundamental principles of the system" and now want more, faster and stronger. Destroy entire Palestinian communities—great, but why take so long? Demolish family homes—sure, but how come they have the (formal, ineffectual) right to appeal? Shoot protesters in Gaza—of course the Supreme Court won't intervene, but why even discuss it? Legalize admission committees—wonderful, but why limit it geographically? The Citizenship Law—a work of true beauty, but why make it a Temporary Order (temporary for 20 years and counting)? The Nation-State Basic Law—thanks for the seal of approval, but shame on you for even hearing the petition.

The deafening silence at the heart of Hayut's speech hinted at what is usually kept under heavy wraps: that Israel's Supreme Court is a stronghold of justice for Jews only.

- Hagai El-Ad

We are witnessing the utter intellectual collapse of the self-righteous policy the Supreme Court tried to lead. Had Hayut even been willing to discard this liberal image and mention some of the hundreds of rulings in the service of Jewish supremacy, it would not have been enough to endear the court to the public—for the attempt to ride the tiger, keep it in check and set its pace is going to hell before our eyes. That is the natural course of a regime whose internal logic promotes the supremacy of one group over another.

Hayut was not sincere in talking about defending human rights from being "crushed," because what she is seeking to protect is the role of the Supreme Court in further crushing Palestinian human rights. Yet she was completely honest in seeking to defend the "fundamental principles of the system"—a system that happens to be a fundamental aspect of the Israeli regime that must be completely overhauled.

The deafening silence at the heart of Justice Hayut's speech hinted at what is usually kept under heavy wraps: that Israel's Supreme Court is a stronghold of justice for Jews only. It does not champion universal human rights, but the human rights of Jews, in a Jewish state.

Editor's note: A version of this article was originally published in Hebrew in Local Call (Sikha Mekomit), a Hebrew-language news site.

Esther Hayut delivers a speech during her swearing-in ceremony as president of Israel's Supreme Court, at the Israeli Presidential residence in Jerusalem, Oct. 26, 2017. (Photo by THOMAS COEX/AFP via Getty Images)

Source: Getty IMages

Tags: IsraelIsrael-PalestinePalestinePalestinians
Previous Post

Sisi Is Driving Egypt Off a Cliff

Next Post

Where Would Rapprochement Between Turkey and Syria Leave the Syrian Opposition?

Related Posts

Democracy In Exile

The Unlearned Lessons of the Iraq War, 20 Years Later: A Democracy in Exile Roundtable

What lessons have still not been learned from the war in Iraq, 20 years after the invasion?

Frederick Deknatel
March 19, 2023
Democracy In Exile

Iraqis Deserve Justice in the Form of Reparations

The illegal, U.S.-led invasion of Iraq 20 years ago cannot be extricated from the deeper, darker history that helped...

Noha Aboueldahab
March 17, 2023
An Israeli bulldozer demolishes a Palestinian house in the Umm Qasas area of Masafer Yatta in the occupied West Bank on July 25, 2022. (Photo by MOSAB SHAWER / AFP) (Photo by MOSAB SHAWER/AFP via Getty Images)
DAWN

Israel/Palestine: Hyundai CE Must End Link With War Crimes in Masafer Yatta

(Seoul, March 16, 2023) Hyundai Construction Equipment (Hyundai CE) must take immediate action to prevent its products' involvement in...

DAWN
March 16, 2023
Democracy In Exile

How to Engage Yemeni Civil Society and Women in Peace

“We need to see women working on the ground get involved if we want peace.”

Kawkab al-Thaibani
March 15, 2023
Next Post
Demonstrators are raising Syrian opposition flags and placards as they rally against a potential rapprochement between Ankara and the Syrian regime in the opposition-held city of Azaz, on the border with Turkey in Syria's northern Aleppo province, on December 30, 2022. (Photo by Rami Alsayed/NurPhoto)

Where Would Rapprochement Between Turkey and Syria Leave the Syrian Opposition?

In this photo provided by Ibrahim Almadi to CNN, Saad Ibrahim Almadi sits in a restaurant in an unidentified place, in the United States, on August 2021.

Saudi Arabia: Lift Travel Ban on US Citizen Released from Saudi Prison

March 21, 2023
An Iraqi woman with her children raise their hands as US soldiers from the 4th Infantry division search their house in Tikrit, 180 Kilometers (110 miles) north of Baghdad, 19 December 2003. US soldiers captured Saddam hiding in a hole at a farm outside his hometown of Tikrit on December 13.         AFP PHOTO/JEWEL SAMAD / AFP PHOTO / JEWEL SAMAD        (Photo credit should read JEWEL SAMAD/AFP via Getty Images)

'A Never-Ending Cycle of Failures.' The Legacy of the Invasion of Iraq, 20 Years On

March 20, 2023

The Unlearned Lessons of the Iraq War, 20 Years Later: A Democracy in Exile Roundtable

March 19, 2023

Categories

  • Advocacy
  • Aid Conditionality
  • Anonymous Interviews
  • Anonymous Interviews Egypt
  • Anonymous Interviews Saudi Arabia
  • Anonymous Interviews UAE
  • Cases
  • Cases Egypt
  • Cases Saudi Arabia
  • Cases UAE
  • Countries
  • Culprits
  • Culprits Egypt
  • Culprits Israel
  • Culprits Saudi Arabia
  • Culprits UAE
  • DAWN
  • Dawn's Advocacy
  • Democracy In Exile
  • Editor's Pick
  • Egypt
  • Feature
  • Fellows
  • Foreign Policy
  • Human Rights
  • Human Rights Go to War
  • International Actors
  • Israel-Palestine
  • Joint Letters
  • Lobbyists
  • Lobbyists Israel Palestine
  • Palestine
  • Political prisoners
  • Press Release Egypt
  • Press Release Israel-Palestine
  • Press Release Saudi Arabia
  • Press Release UAE
  • Press Releases
  • Saudi Arabia
  • UAE
  • Uncategorized
  • United Nations
  • US – Egypt
  • US – Saudi Arabia
  • US – UAE
  • USA
  • Yemen Conference

SUPPORT OUR MISSION

Donate Today

About Us

Democracy for the Arab World Now (DAWN) is a nonprofit organization that promotes democracy, the rule of law, and human rights for all of the peoples of the Middle East and North Africa (MENA).

Support Us

Donate Now

Newsletter

Facebook Twitter Instagram Linkedin Youtube

© DAWN All rights reserved. | Website Design by KRS Creative.

DONATE TODAY